May 25, 2009

The Bread Baker's Apprentice Challenge: Bagels

Labels: ,

toppings: sesame seeds, poppy seeds, salt

It's the third week of The Bread Baker's Apprentice Challenge and bagels are in the spotlight. I made bagels twice before, the first one about 5 years ago was a total disaster, and recently as a recipe tester for Peter Reinhart's which went great.

Although they are not as shiny as store-bought, I am very happy with the BBA bagels because they came out chewy, dense, and heavy just the way I like them. Delicious!

I made half a recipe, added 1 tablespoon of vital wheat gluten to the bread flour, and I also used barley malt syrup both in the dough and poaching water. I should have increased the amount of baking soda for shinier bagels. The dough yield was seven 4-ounce pieces which are too big IMHO. I might reduce each ball of dough to 3.5 ounces next time. For the topping I used black and white sesame seeds, black and white poppy seeds, and salt. It is worth making these bagels, they taste superior to store-bought.

this gram/ounce weighing scale with tare is one of my favorite kitchen gadgets

shaping the bagel

ready for an overnight stay in the refrigerator

the seven bagels +

toasted and slathered with honey-nut cream cheese

flavor 5
texture 5
visual appeal 4
ease of preparation 3.5 (shaping is not so easy)
performance 5
worth 5
Total: 27.5
Average: 4.58

The BBA Challenge is hosted by Nicole of Pinch My Salt


Sidney said...

Is their a dish or something you can't cook?

susies1955 said...

Ok was PETER REINHART at your house?
Your bagels are perfect. Do you live in northern NY so I can come over and be taught???
Great job,

An Out of Town Mom said...

These look perfect! I am impressed, and a wee bit jealous!

oggi said...

Sidney, yes a turducken!:D

Susie, thanks.
That's why I love Peter's books, it's almost as if he's right beside me guiding me along, heheh.

An Out of Town Mom, thanks.:)

Nico said...

very nice, very nice.

gaaarp said...

Very nice post. And your bagels are beautiful! The little one is too cute to eat.

haleysuzanne said...

These are beautiful! I hope mine turn out as well. And, I just noticed you are in Ashland. I live in West Point!

Cindy said...

Your bagels are perfect. Mine are sleeping in the fridge tonight and tomorrow I will bake them. I am curious about the vital wheat. I had to mail order high gluten flour from King Arthur and they charged me $25.00 in shipping. (I live in Canada). I wonder how much different the bagels taste with regular flour plus vital wheat verses those made with HG flour.

oggi said...

Nico, thanks.:)

Gaaarp, thanks. The small one got eaten first.:)

Haleysuzanne, I'll be checking out your bagels. I'm actually in Northern VA, about an hour from Washington, DC.:)

Cindy, I found another source for high gluten flour. If the flour is as good as KA's I'll link you the site and I'll probably blog about it too.
The VWG package says to add 1 tablespoon to whole wheat/whole grain for better rise. I don't know if adding it to bread flour makes a difference, I have not compared:)

Laura said...

Great job! I loved making them!

oggi said...

Laura, thanks. Me too, I enjoyed making them.:)

MyKitchenInHalfCups said...

Good golly you've got gorgeous bagels. Wonderful.
Know just what you mean about the scale, I can't do without mine anymore.

oggi said...

MyKitchenInHalfCups, thanks.

David Hinske said...

I used King Arthur bread flour and ALSO refridgerated the starter overnight. I'm at altitude (7,000 feet) in Taos and the baking time needed to be doubled! Anyway, eventually they came out great. Full of flavor, nicely crisp on the outside, soft and chewy on the inside. It's so hard to find good bagels anywhere outside of NYC, much less here in the high desert. These hit the spot.

Post a Comment

Design by New WP Themes | Bloggerized by Lasantha -